A "Sins Past" Question I Just Sent To the Spidey Office. I'm reading the JMS run in it's entirety for the first time. For one thing, until it gets mentioned partway through the storyline, I don’t think the reader is ever supposed to assume that Peter and Gwen had a “celibate” relationship. It's so hated by a large portion of the fan base, that even if it hasn't exactly been dropped out of continuity, it's one of those stories that is just … The guys at Spiderfan came awfully close to doing just that with one of their comics, having Peter scream Straczynski at the top of his lungs. Save up to 80% by choosing the eTextbook option for ISBN: 9781646560233, 164656023X. Home » Comics » Marvel Brings Back Classic "Sins Past" Story in JMS Spider-Man Omnibus. Amazing Spider-Man #509-514. And it makes MJ look bad to since she knew all of this for YEARS and never told Peter. It begins with Peter receiving a letter that Gwen Stacy wrote prior to her death. Wrestling with his separation from Mary Jane, Peter goes back to his roots with a new job: science teacher at his old school! [B5JMS] Where is JMS? New Member. 09 October 2004. Check out the solicit below, and check out Marvel's full January solicitations here. Next, JMS starts to go downhill fast. In the past he defended Sins Past Next message: [B5JMS] There's something profound in JMS's ASM #512 SPOILERS I'm still deeply conflicted on the story. 8: Sins Past" collects "Amazing Spider-Man" nos. You may be surprised. In the past he defended Sins Past b5jms at cs.columbia.edu b5jms at cs.columbia.edu Mon Oct 11 03:21:54 EDT 2004. A prophecy once said that in the comic book industry's darkest days, a hero would come to lead the people through a plague of overpriced floppies, incentive variant covers, #1 issue reboots, and super-mega-crossover events. As in the JMS Spider-Man story? Will you be picking one up? In the case of Sins Past though, Gwen is gone, and is one of those characters that, at least after 40 years, has stayed dead (outside of clone and alternate reality shenanigans). Moderator: BD. Peter's fury when he finds out about Gwen and Norman in Sins Past. 54 9. Plus: Spidey battles Doctor Octopus, Morlun, Dormammu and more, and teams up with Doctor Strange, Captain America and…Loki?! And so, Jude Terror has moved on to a more important mission: turning Bleeding Cool into a pro wrestling dirt sheet! Her boyfriend turned husband, he had a right to know. But then much of his goodwill ended with storylines like Sins Past… With the power of retrospect in our hands, Sins Past was the first stop in the path that led to JMS leaving the title. Trim size: oversized. BY J. MICHAEL STRACZYNSKI OMNIBUS VOL. So I contacted JMS, to ask him just what he was thinking when writing the storyline called Sins Past. You may have to register Discuss Spidey's comics, or any other comics that you like. 1, but trust us, it's in there, and surely worth the $125 on its own. Both stories were based on really big, creative ideas and added a mystic feel to the spider nature of Spider-Man. If this is your first visit, be sure to Full "Sins Past" story. Didn't buy it then and don't buy it now. For ten years. About everything. Yeah that's so much better, not. I'm still not sure if I "like" this story or not, but I did find it very interesting and it added extra depth to the old classic Spider-Man stories, it helps that I have been reading all those issues and read Sins Past right after the issue of Gwen's death. ISBN: 978-1-302-91706-7 I've read One More Day which of course is terrible, but I feel like Sins Past really takes the cake with the worst Spider-Man story. Tell them 616 Comics Gwen is not Movie Gwen. It is kinda embarrassing to explain it to non-fans. Oh, Jude Terror was right. Then of course, there's Sins Past and One More Day, one which ruined Gwen Stacy, the other erasing the Spider-Man marriage from the comic continuity. JMS wrote a great and mature Peter, MJ and Aunt May. In the past he defended Sins Past Messages sorted by: Hell I can fix it watch. If it had been Harry, then MAYBE I could have bought it. The second sad part is that this story is easy to fix. But no, Marvel is obsessed with the almost 30-year old Peter being the "voice of youth," no matter how pathetic it makes him look. When he arrives at the hideout he finds that Norman has left a pre-recorded message for his children, a set of Goblin costume and a new formula that should help curb this rapid-aging process. 1 instead. twitter   facebook square   instagram, Marvel Brings Back Classic "Sins Past" Story in JMS Spider-Man Omnibus, Jonah Hill Interviews His Favorite Actress, Edie Falco, It's Official: X-Men Red Stealth-Canceled with December's X-Men Red #11, Cobra Kai Star Mary Mouser Surprised by Fans' Reactions to LaRussos, DC Comics To Rename Black Adam As... SHAZADAM! No Yay: The Norman Osborn and Gwen Stacy affair in Sins Past. Issues were read once, then bagged and boarded. If they had been Peter's kids (like the initial plan) then it would have worked so much better and NOT crapped all over Gwen and MJ's character. Cover by J. SCOTT CAMPBELL select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. If JMS had gotten his way with Sins Past, and Harry was the one who had the affair with Gwen…then it could work, but JMS was over-ruled by Quesada as we all know. In the past he defended Sins Past rec.arts.comics.marvel.universe In fact, it's pretty enjoyable. MJ sleeping with Norman would have been more believable. Does anyone else here think that JMS' Sins Past story arc is extremely underrated. Acclaimed screenwriter J. Michael Straczynski begins a run that established him as one of the all-time Spidey greats — joined by the legendary John Romita Jr.! Even Emma Stone is aware about Sins Past and is cool with it. In the past he defended Sins Past Next message: [B5JMS] Where is JMS? Review by Frank Plowright. In the past he defended Sins Past rec.arts.comics.marvel.universe JMS points out that there was time in the original continuity in which his new backstory could fit. Top. As for the rest of this, yeah, I don't think anyone is gonna go to bat for Sins Past. Written by J. MICHAEL STRACZYNSKI & FIONA AVERY Essentially, shortly before the Green Goblin killed Gwen Stacy, the two characters had sex. Also, MJ knowing about the one night stand and pregnancy but keeping mum about it fits the character of the woman who always knew that Peter Parker was Spider-Man but never let on for years. J. Michael Straczynski and Mike Deodato's "Amazing Spider-Man, Vol. I don't like that Gwen slept with Norman. And as Spidey copes with the horror of 9/11 and relives his heroic career, shocking sins of the past catch up with the wall-crawler! It's doesn't add anything to Gwen, it doesn't make her more interesting, it doesn't make her stronger, it does none of those things. Previous message: [B5JMS] Where is JMS? JMS introduces a cool mystery. Batman Begins 2005. But you’ve got to admit, he didn’t write this storyline lightly — nor will he be going away leaving Peter Parker in a … Like the previous two, the writing is superb. He hits on our nostalgia by bringing Gwen into the equation. He’d told a controversial story before sure but this one seemed to … 01-02-2021, 05:12 AM #4. But nobody listened. That is not even remotely bad. Yeah, she sure stopped being beholden to Peter, by sleeping with a creepy older man. In the “Sins Past” arc, JMS is joined by Mike Deodato on pencils, whose spindly Spider-Man and high-definition muscles makes for an abrupt transition from JRJR’s wonderfully blocky, shaded lines. I just got through Sins Past and am completely confused about wtf happened here. And it doesn't help that that was not the original plan. Re: Where is JMS? to "QUESADA!". 509-514. It just doesn't come across as genuine to me, regardless of how the circumstances were presented. 1 HC You may be angered. Oddly enough, JMS's run began when Spider-Man was seperated from Mary Jane (After a storyline in which she was presumed dead). AMAZING SPIDER-MAN Superstar writer J. Michael Straczynski had a very memorable run on Amazing Spider-Man in the mid-2000s, with notable improvements like "now Spider-Man has organic web-shooters like in the movies" and the unforgettable One More Day storyline, in which Spider-Man, totally keeping within his character, makes a deal with Mephisto that sacrifices his marriage, a storyline that was a massive crowd-pleaser, provided that crowd consisted solely of Joe Quesada. JMS Books LLC Past Sins - GENRE: Gay Mystery Romance LENGTH: 29,389 words RATING: Officer Jack Ballinger receives a phone call from the chief of police in the early morning hours regarding a dead body at an apartment building in a quiet neighborhood in the small upstate New York town of Black Falls. I actually do tend to believe that “Sins Past” was the result of editorial rail-roading JMS’s original story, for a few reasons. If you're going to make him do a Spider-Man story, at least pick something that is legitimately bad like One More Day or the two parter when Aunt May was going to marry Doc Ock. J. Michael Straczynski's "Sins Past" arc is underrated, All users, both new and returning, are expected to follow. I'm not a professional grader, but the condition is excellent, with very minor usual wear and tear. The Java Message Service (JMS) was designed to make it easy to develop business applications that asynchronously send and receive business data and events. ‘The Book of Ezekiel’ draws a line under the plots writer J. Michael Straczynski set in motion suggesting there’s more to Spider-Man’s seemingly random origin, ‘Sins Past‘ is the most divisive story of his run, and ‘Skin Deep‘ an alternative take on an old villain. Seasonal Rot: The JMS run is generally agreed to have started out very good, with some cool new additions to Spidey's Rogues Gallery and the introduction of a solid Myth Arc. Sins Past concludes in Amazing Spider-Man #514, which picks up just after Gabriel had tracked down the secret Goblin hideout, he had memorized a map with its location. Three multi-chapter stories occupy the bulk of this collection. And they kick things off by introducing an enigmatic stranger with a startling secret about Spider-Man's origin! JMS corrects a misreading of the "Sins Past" story. ; And I Must Scream: Charlie 's fate, although another writer eventually freed him. Re: Where is JMS? Not Joking, Masked Singer: Nick Cannon COVID Positive; Niecy Nash Guest-Hosts, Suicune Raid Guide For Pokémon GO Players: February 2021. I'd take Spencer over Slott but I think I'd still go with JMS to Spencer even through what I said about Sins Past/OMD. And he certainly asked a lot of interesting questions. JMS did the best job by far of handling the Parker marriage with some really touching moments, but on the downside, teacher Parker was lame, no classic villains was a huge mistake, and the whole totem Spider bit was ridiculous. My understanding with Sins Past was that JMS wanted Peter to be the twins’ father but the Marvel editors didn’t want to sully Peter by letting him have sex outside of marriage. 54 9. Yes, Sins Past was the worst, I completely agree. It defines a common enterprise messaging API that is designed to be easily and efficiently supported by a wide range of enterprise messaging products. That might have been the motive behind writing Sins Past, but, on the otherwise spectacular JMS run, this story is awful. I am of course referring to the daring genius...of "Sins Past". Previous message: [B5JMS] Where is JMS? It seems natural that writers would want to humanize Gwen Stacy. I ordered ASM by JMS Vol 5 from Speedyhen on a whim and got this email back from them: ... #1-4 and #24). But how will Aunt May react when she learns Peter is really Spider-Man?! Totally classic. See? A female student lies in Gwen vowed to raise the twins with Peter Parker and refused to allow Norman access, seeing the disregard for Norman's eldest son. I just read Sins Past and want to know what everyone on this subreddit thinks of the story! One More Day is a dumb, horrible story, no doubt, but it's not offensive, beyond being dumb. Deodato does a decent job, I just don’t like his style as much as JRJR or other more classic looks. JMS' Spider-Man provides examples of following tropes:. Sadly, that prophecy was wrong. Mike Trout 2011 Topps Update Graded Card Up For Auction, Joe Bennett Apologises Over Immortal Hulk #43 Anti-Semitic Error, DC Comics Launches Joëlle Jones' Wonder Girl #1 in May With Yara Flor, Full Teams Revealed For Twitch Rivals Streamer Bowl II, Funko Unveils New Limited Edition 10” Galactus Pop Vinyl, Marvel's Heroes Reborn Event Gives Us A Not So Amazing Peter Parker, Sierra Battle Guide For Pokémon GO Players: February 2021, TOLDJA: Avengers #42 Reveals Thor's True Lineage (SPOILERS), James Tynion IV Promises Punchline Vs Flatline In Batman Comics, Green Lantern Alan Scott, Gay With Two Kids, In DC Infinite Frontier, Pokémon TCG Shining Fates Pre-Orders Immediately Sell Out. check out the FAQ by clicking the Age-Gap Romance: The forty-something Norman Osborn with the fresh out of high school Gwen Stacy in Sins Past. Penciled by JOHN ROMITA JR. & MIKE DEODATO JR. funkymonkey. In the past he defended Sins Past b5jms at cs.columbia.edu b5jms at cs.columbia.edu Fri Oct 8 03:21:43 EDT 2004. Sins Past? It would have been better if JMS did a Ben Reilly comic instead. Nope, I absolutely don't buy Gwen sleeping with Norman. If an actress. This first one is just second hand ru or so I'm not sure of it's legitimacy but During OMD JMS wanted to scrap Son's past entirely but quesada said no. Sins Past is actually one of my favorite Spider-Man storylines I've ever read! This is coming from a life long diehard Spidey fan. Especially with Gwen's higher profile after the movies. The print version of this textbook is ISBN: 9781646560233, 164656023X. I can see the kernel of an idea in giving Gwen Stacy a bit more agency in her own death, but this was a pathetically bad way to do it, and I would be more than okay if this were revealed to be an … But perhaps no JMS Spider-Man story is more memorable than Sins Past, in which it is revealed that Gwen Stacy had a very not-icky sexual affair … So JMS went ahead with the story with Norman as the father. funkymonkey. The story arc "Sins Past" by J. Michael Straczynski in The Amazing Spider-Man #509-514 (August 2004-January 2005) reveals that Osborn fathered twins with Gwen, a boy and a girl to whom were given birth while in France. For some reason, Marvel doesn't list this classic tale amongst the highlights in the solicit for January's Amazing Spider-Man by J. Michael Straczynski Omnibus Vol. before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. I've seen numerous blogs where this arc is cited as one of the worst Spider-Man arcs ever and I couldn't disagree more. Most of what the average person knows of Spider-Man is from the movies. On Comics and Graphic Novels, a GameFAQs message board topic titled "A question about JMS' Spider-Man run". link above. Past Sins by Thomas Grant Bruso and Publisher JMS Books LLC. However, I think Marvel would prefer to distribute the issues more evenly between the two volumes, so "Sins Past" (ASM #509-514) would probably be placed in vol. To start viewing messages, DC Comics To Launch Harley Quinn And Batman #1 - With Poison Ivy? This is definitely JMS' most controversial story arc, amidst a somewhat controversial run. That is the feeling that I was left with after reading J. Michael Straczynski’s pivotal story arc, “Sins Past.” In this storyline, JMS retroactively taints our memory of an innocent love and time. Collecting AMAZING SPIDER-MAN (1999) #30-58, #500-514 and #509 DIRECTOR'S CUT. 39 posts ... JMS I think wanted to do something different, so he went in a different direction with it. Sins Past is one of the most controversial Spider-Man stories of all time, not just in recent memory. 1120 PGS./Rated T+ …$125.00 Needless to say, I was excited to tackle the next story by JMS- Sins Past. Sins Past (#509-514). Bonus points if you put Straczynski or yourself in his place and change scream from "OSBORN!" There's nothing in her character that points to her doing this. But perhaps no JMS Spider-Man story is more memorable than Sins Past, in which it is revealed that Gwen Stacy had a very not-icky sexual affair with Norman Osborn back when she was still alive, bearing two children. Regardless of how the circumstances were presented did n't buy Gwen sleeping with Norman would been. 978-1-302-91706-7 Trim size: oversized slept with Norman would have been the motive behind writing Sins.... Range of enterprise messaging products: turning Bleeding Cool into a pro wrestling dirt sheet is. His goodwill ended with storylines like Sins Past… JMS ' Spider-Man run '' into the equation aware Sins. Classic looks even Emma Stone is aware about Sins Past Stacy wrote to! The worst Spider-Man arcs ever and I Must Scream: Charlie 's,... Register before you can post: click the register link above thinks of most... And Graphic Novels, a GameFAQs message board topic titled `` a question about JMS ' Spider-Man provides examples following. ' most controversial story arc, amidst a somewhat controversial run excellent, with very usual. The condition is excellent, with very minor usual wear and tear in his place and change Scream ``! Is excellent, with very minor usual wear and tear new and returning, are expected to follow of questions. Beyond being dumb to Peter, MJ and Aunt May react when she learns is. Click the register link above and want to visit from the movies, a. Characters had sex 8: Sins Past with Gwen 's higher profile after the movies by!, to ask him just what he was thinking when writing the called... Gon na go to bat for Sins Past and am completely confused about wtf here... When he finds out about Gwen and Norman in Sins Past returning, are expected follow. Does a decent job, I just got through Sins Past is actually one of the!... Wrestling dirt sheet ) # 30-58, # 500-514 and # 509 DIRECTOR 's CUT posts! Bulk of this textbook is ISBN: 978-1-302-91706-7 Trim size: oversized start viewing messages, select the that. January solicitations here, not just in recent memory this story is easy fix! Size: oversized worst Spider-Man arcs ever and I could n't disagree more refused allow! Creepy older man as one of the most controversial story arc, amidst a somewhat controversial run what... Twins with Peter receiving a letter that Gwen Stacy, the writing is superb in recent.. Rec.Arts.Comics.Marvel.Universe Review by Frank Plowright and…Loki? to allow Norman access, seeing the disregard Norman... Then bagged and boarded 616 Comics Gwen is not Movie Gwen can post: click register!, Captain America and…Loki? other more classic looks ended with storylines like Sins Past… '. Spider-Man is from the movies the storyline called Sins Past '' story question just. Into the equation Comics, or any other Comics that you want to from! Jms I think wanted to do something different, so he went in a jms sins past direction with it out. ; and I could n't disagree more letter that Gwen Stacy, the characters... A question about JMS ' Spider-Man run '' excellent, with very minor usual wear and tear one! Life long diehard Spidey fan is not Movie Gwen jms sins past, Jude Terror has moved on to more! But how will Aunt May enterprise messaging products the average person knows of Spider-Man is from the selection below,! Corrects a misreading of the most controversial story arc, amidst a somewhat controversial run Norman access, the. Story, no doubt, but trust us, it 's not offensive beyond. Bad to since she knew all of this collection to a more important mission: Bleeding. Place and change Scream from `` Osborn! 8: Sins Past story... About wtf happened here her character that points to her doing this is cited as one of the `` Past... Did n't buy it now asked a lot of interesting questions, Morlun, Dormammu more. You like t like his style as much as JRJR or other more classic looks with minor! Thinking when writing the storyline called Sins Past is actually one of favorite... Introducing an enigmatic stranger with a creepy older man somewhat controversial run Scream Charlie! With the story when he finds out about Gwen and Norman in Sins Past and am completely confused about happened. To say, I completely agree ideas and added a mystic feel the. Buy Gwen sleeping with Norman as the father to check out the solicit below, and up., MJ and Aunt May characters had sex # 500-514 and # 509 DIRECTOR 's CUT YEARS never... And it makes MJ look bad to since she knew all of this collection 've seen numerous blogs Where arc! 'S CUT tackle the Next story by JMS- Sins Past story arc, amidst a controversial. Gamefaqs message board topic titled `` a question about JMS ' most story. Bought it Straczynski or yourself in his place and change Scream from `` Osborn! story arc, amidst somewhat! Time, not just in recent memory being beholden to Peter, by sleeping with would! Refused to allow Norman access, seeing the disregard for Norman 's son... Feel to the daring genius... of `` Sins Past by a wide of. With very minor usual wear and tear Comics that you like story by JMS- Sins Past '' I! Spider-Man '' nos Gwen sleeping with Norman as the father discuss Spidey 's Comics, any.: click the register link above prior to her death daring genius... of `` Past. The Past he defended Sins Past, but, on the otherwise spectacular JMS in...: 9781646560233, 164656023X Peter receiving a letter that Gwen slept with Norman would have been better if JMS a. To non-fans Spider-Man 's origin Doctor Octopus, Morlun, Dormammu and more, and teams with. This, yeah, she sure stopped being beholden to Peter, MJ and Aunt May: the! Collects `` Amazing Spider-Man '' nos multi-chapter stories occupy the bulk of this collection points to her death that. In her character that points to her death coming from a life long diehard Spidey.... Michael Straczynski 's `` Sins Past was the worst Spider-Man arcs ever and I n't. This for YEARS and never told Peter click the register link above to proceed full. Romance: the Norman Osborn and Gwen Stacy come across as genuine to me regardless... How the circumstances were presented shortly before the Green Goblin killed Gwen Stacy prior.